As the need for heightened security at home and in businesses has become increasingly paramount, various lock manufacturers have taken center stage with innovative lock designs that are durable, user-friendly, and secure. In the midst of this rising demand, three names have emerged as dominant figures – Emtek, Baldwin, and Schlage.
Each brand comes with its unique set of offerings, all boasting a blend of top-quality materials, advanced technology, and functional design.
This detailed article will take a deep dive into these three brands, comparing them in terms of safety, ease of use and installation, durability, and software. Here’s a tabulated summary:
| Feature/Brand | Emtek | Baldwin | Schlage |
| High-Level Security | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Easy Installation | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| User-Friendly | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Durability | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| High-Quality Software | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Extensive Warranty | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Luxury Design | Yes | Yes | No |
| Wide Range of Styles | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Wide Compatibility with Home Automation Systems | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Affordable Range | No | No | Yes |
Following an in-depth comparison, so you can choose the best option for your home. Here’s another interesting three-way comparison between Schlage, Emtek and Kwikset.
Safety
The fundamental purpose of any lock, whether traditional or smart, is to provide security. Let’s see how these three brands measure up.
Emtek
Emtek locks are designed with security at the forefront. Their deadbolts, in particular, are rated highly in terms of burglary resistance.
Emtek’s electronic locks come equipped with a highly secure coding system that ensures that each digital key is unique, reducing the risk of unauthorized access. The locks have a built-in feature of automatically getting locked after some time.
Baldwin
Baldwin’s mechanical locks are made from solid brass or steel, providing excellent resistance against forceful entry. Baldwin’s SmartKey technology is noteworthy, as it allows users to re-key their locks easily, preventing unauthorized access in case a key gets lost.
Furthermore, Baldwin’s Evolved smart locks are built with advanced Bluetooth technology, offering a new level of home security and convenience.
Schlage
Schlage locks, both smart and traditional, are widely recognized for their security features. The ANSI Grade 1 certification, the highest residential security rating a lock can achieve, graces several Schlage models.
Schlage’s smart locks offer unique passcodes for different users and have built-in alarm technology that sends alerts based on the level of sensitivity set by the user.
All in all, I consider these three to be equal with regards to security.
Ease of Use and Installation
While safety is a priority, a lock’s usability and ease of installation are also crucial factors to consider.
Emtek
Despite their high-end nature, Emtek locks are surprisingly easy to install, often requiring just a screwdriver and the provided instructions. Their smart locks are compatible with standard doors and don’t require any extra drilling.
The user interface on Emtek’s smart locks is intuitive, with features such as one-touch locking and fingerprint recognition making daily usage seamless.
Baldwin
Baldwin installation is usually straightforward with clear instructions, although some models may require professional installation. Baldwin’s smart locks feature intuitive user interfaces, and most models are compatible with popular home automation systems, adding to their ease of use.
Schlage
Schlage locks excel in the ease of installation and usage of its locks. Their “Snap & Stay” design makes installing a Schlage lock a breeze.
Most of their smart locks can be installed with just a screwdriver and are easy to set up with their accompanying app. Schlage smart locks are also known for their compatibility with a wide array of home automation systems.
In my opinion, Schlage takes the lead in this regard with Emtek being a close second.
Durability
Durability is a crucial characteristic for any lock system, as it directly impacts long-term functionality and security.
Emtek
Emtek locks are known for their exceptional durability. They utilize top-quality materials like solid brass and steel for their locks, ensuring longevity and wear-resistance.
Baldwin
Baldwin is known for making some heavy-duty solid brass door locks and handles.Their solid brass or steel construction ensures a long lifespan and resistance against physical attacks.
Schlage
Schlage’s ANSI Grade 1 certification on many models not only testifies to their security but also their durability. Many Schlage locks also offer additional protective features such as anti-tarnish finishes.
All three of these are highly durable with little difference, practically. However, I would give this category to schlage simply because of its ANSI certification.
Software
Smart locks are as good as the software they operate on.
Emtek
Emtek’s smart locks can be managed using an app, which is user-friendly and intuitive. The app allows you to control and monitor your locks remotely, create unique access codes, and receive alerts. Emtek smart locks also integrate well with popular home automation systems, providing users with additional convenience.
Baldwin
Baldwin’s Evolved smart locks leverage the Kevo App, a user-friendly platform that allows users to lock and unlock doors remotely, track lock activity, and distribute eKeys to family and friends.
The Baldwin Home App, used for managing their Home Connect locks, offers similar functionalities. Baldwin locks also play well with popular smart home ecosystems, including Amazon Alexa and Google Home.
Schlage
Schlage’s smart locks run on reliable and easy-to-use software. The Schlage Home App and Schlage Encode App, depending on the lock model, are designed to allow users to manage their locks, set unique access codes, and monitor access.
Schlage takes the lead here in my opinion because its app is really simple and straight-to-the-point.
Warranty
Now, if you’re going for smart locks, the only aspect that is equally important as the technology used is the warranty. Let’s review the warranty policies of our three contenders.
Emtek
Emtek displays confidence in the longevity and reliability of its products with a non-transferable limited lifetime warranty for all door hardware products. The electronic components in Emtek’s product line are covered under a 2-year warranty. This period should offer enough time to gauge the functionality and reliability of the electronic aspects of their products.
Baldwin
Baldwin Hardware has a somewhat more complex warranty policy, with the duration depending on the series of the product. The Estate series door hardware comes with a warranty ranging from 1 to 5 years, depending on the finish and mechanical components. This gives users assurance on the durability of both the aesthetic and functional aspects of the lock.
On the other hand, the Reserve series is backed by a 25-year warranty, signaling a high degree of faith in the longevity of this product line by Baldwin.
At the very top, the Prestige series is backed by a lifetime warranty, which underscores the high-quality build and materials used in these products.
Schlage
Schlage continues its trend of trustworthiness and reliability by offering a limited lifetime mechanical and finish warranty. For the electronic components of its locks, Schlage offers a 3-year limited warranty. This allows the user ample time to ensure the electronics are performing well.
Importantly, Schlage demonstrates their commitment to customer satisfaction with dedicated customer support to address any concerns or issues the user might face.
Thus Schlage manages to outshine its competition once again with its generous warranty.
Price and Value for Money
Emtek
Emtek offers a wider variety of contemporary and high-quality door hardware alternatives at lower pricing compared to Baldwin and Schlage. As a result, many people who want high-quality items but don’t want to spend a fortune choose Emtek.
Our verdict is that Emtek gives the best value for money.
Baldwin
Baldwin’s premium Estate Series is noted for its exquisite design and construction, hence it comes at a higher price. Baldwin is known for producing high-quality products, therefore some buyers may feel the premium is warranted.
It’s true that even the more reasonably priced Baldwin Reserve and Prestige Series alternatives will cost more than equivalent Emtek fixtures.
Schlage
Schlage has repeatedly established itself to be one of the most trustworthy and reliable companies in the lock market. Products like the Connect and Sense are great to utilize, while the Encode provides superior security.
People who are looking to get the most out of their home security investment can benefit from installing Schlage smart locks. These locks have the highest possible security certification and can come handy if we talk about value for money.
Among these three, Emtek is the most affordable one, followed closely by Schlage. In terms of value for money, Schlage manages to crawl ahead of Emtek.
Conclusion
Choosing between Emtek, Baldwin, and Schlage is a challenging task. All three brands provide top-quality locks that are secure, easy to install and use, durable, and equipped with advanced software for smart lock models.
In light of the above discussion, it is evident that Schlage wins the most categories and also provides the highest value for money. Thus, I would always go for Schlage.
However, if budgetary constraints are your primary concern, Emtek would be the way to go as they provide most of the functionality at an objectively cheaper price.
Related articles: